top of page
Search

Rare Colored Potato Varieties: A Guide for Cooks

12 hours ago
8 min read

Last Updated: November 21, 2026

Quick Summary

Colored potato varieties include purple-fleshed types, pink and red fingerlings, and blue-fleshed heirlooms, each with different flavor and cooking behavior. Purple types are earthy and dense, while waxy pink and red fingerlings hold their shape well in salads and roasting.

  • Purple-fleshed potatoes are medium to high in starch and can crumble if overcooked.

  • Steam or roast purple potatoes instead of boiling them in a large volume of water to keep their color bright.

  • Waxy colored varieties hold their shape well for salads, while floury types can break down and turn grainy.

  • Cook colored potatoes whole and skin-on, then cool them completely before cutting to protect texture and color.

  • Heirloom names are not regulated, so ask sellers for flesh color and starch level before buying.

Want colored potatoes you can't buy at the store?

Soda Springs Solar Gardens LLC sells early generation, organic seed potatoes for home gardens.

Table of Contents

If you have only ever bought russets and yellow Yukons, you are missing the colored potato varieties that change what a plate can look like. Rare colored potato varieties for cooking range from deep purple and blue flesh to pink-skinned fingerlings with a firm, waxy bite.

The case for growing them comes down to three things: flavor, color, and the chance to grow something your grocery store will never stock. Many colored potatoes have a nuttier, earthier taste than common white varieties. Their flesh can hold its color when cooked properly, though this depends on the type.

Consider this a practical starting point. We cover the main groups, how each behaves in the pan and the oven, and where to find seed stock.

Purple Potato Varieties and Their Flavor Profiles

Purple potatoes get their color from anthocyanin pigments concentrated in the skin and flesh. Flavor varies more than most cooks expect. Some purple types taste mild and slightly sweet, while others lean earthy and dense.

Hands holding freshly harvested purple and blue colored potato varieties in a wooden crate with garden soil.

Purple-fleshed potatoes are generally medium to high in starch, so they hold together well when boiled but can crumble if overcooked. A sample of Sample Purple Peruvian lets you taste the flavor described here before you commit a whole bed to it. Growers who want the same variety for their own plot can go straight to the Purple Peruvian product page.

Watch out: purple flesh often loses its vivid color if boiled in a large volume of water. Steam or roast it instead to keep the color bright.

Red, Pink, and Blue Fingerling Potato Varieties

Fingerlings are long, slender potatoes that cook quickly and split cleanly for salads. Red and pink fingerlings tend to have firm, waxy flesh that stays intact in the pan. Blue fingerlings are less common and often show the deepest color when roasted whole.

A reader interested in pink potatoes can order a sample of Kerrs Pink to try the texture firsthand. Fingerlings of this kind are hard to find in ordinary retail stores, and where to find rare fingerling potatoes covers the places that do carry them.

Heirloom Potato Varieties: Regional Origins and Cooking Characteristics

Heirloom potatoes are open-pollinated varieties passed down within growing regions, and their cooking behavior varies enough that the name alone tells you little. The useful way to read an heirloom listing is to look at three things: flesh color, starch level, and skin thickness. Those three traits predict whether a variety will hold its shape in a salad, mash smoothly, or crisp in the oven.

Here is how several well-known heirloom and colored varieties are generally described in the kitchen, using the traits most sellers and growers report:

  • Purple Peruvian (purple flesh): Medium-to-high starch with dense, earthy flesh. Best roasted in wedges or steamed whole; it can crumble if boiled hard in a large pot. Color holds best when the cut surfaces are exposed to dry heat rather than submerged.

  • Kerrs Pink (pink skin, white flesh): A waxy, firm heirloom from Scotland that keeps its shape after boiling. Best for potato salad, gratins, and pan-frying; less suited to mashing, where it can turn gluey.

  • All Blue (blue skin and flesh): All-purpose starch level with deep violet flesh. Roasts well and makes a striking mash, but the color fades in long boils, so steam or bake when appearance matters.

  • Russian Banana (yellow fingerling): Waxy and nutty, a classic fingerling for roasting whole and for salads. Holds shape reliably.

  • French Fingerling (red skin, yellow flesh): Waxy with a smooth, buttery texture. Roast whole or slice cold for salads.

  • Red Gold (red skin, yellow flesh): Waxy to medium starch; good all-around performer for boiling, roasting, and salads.

A common pattern is that the more vividly colored the flesh, the more the pigment sits near the surface and the more careful you need to be with peeling and long water contact. If you want to taste a variety before committing garden space, a Sample Purple Peruvian is a low-risk way to check flavor and texture, and growers ready to plant can go to the Purple Peruvian product page.

Watch out: heirloom names are not regulated, so the same name can describe slightly different stock from different sellers. Ask for the flesh color and starch level, not just the name, before you buy seed or tubers.

The cooking behavior of several well-known heirloom and colored varieties is summarised below, using the traits sellers and growers report.

Variety

Flesh or skin

Best use

Purple Peruvian

Purple flesh, medium-to-high starch

Roasted in wedges or steamed whole

Kerrs Pink

Pink skin, white flesh, waxy

Potato salad, gratins, pan-frying

All Blue

Blue skin and flesh, all-purpose starch

Roasting and striking mash

Russian Banana

Yellow fingerling, waxy

Roasting whole and salads

French Fingerling

Red skin, yellow flesh, waxy

Roast whole or slice cold for salads

Red Gold

Red skin, yellow flesh, waxy to medium starch

All-around boiling, roasting, salads

Best Potatoes for Roasting: Color Retention and Cooking Methods

Roasting is where colored potatoes shine, but color retention depends on the variety and how you prepare it. Cut them into even pieces, dry them well, and roast at a moderately high heat. Waxy colored types generally hold their shape well. Floury types can brown unevenly.

Avoid soaking cut potatoes for long periods before roasting, since this can leach pigment and reduce crispness. Keep the pieces in a single layer so they caramelize rather than steam.

Potato Varieties for Salads: Texture, Starch, and Serving Tips

Potato salad lives or dies on starch level. Waxy potatoes generally stay intact when tossed; floury potatoes tend to break down and turn the dressing grainy. For a colored salad, you want waxy to medium-waxy varieties so the cubes stay sharp and the color stays visible.

Best colored varieties for salad, by behavior:

  • Kerrs Pink: Firm, waxy, pink-skinned. Holds a clean dice and pairs well with a sharp vinaigrette.

  • French Fingerling: Waxy with a buttery finish. Slice into coins after cooling rather than dicing hot.

  • Russian Banana: Nutty and firm; roast first, then dress while just warm.

  • All Blue: Medium starch; dice and steam rather than boil to keep the violet color from bleeding into the dressing.

  • Purple Peruvian: Dense and earthy; best cut into larger chunks and dressed lightly, since it can crumble if overworked.

Method that protects both texture and color:

  1. Cook whole and skin-on in salted water or, better, steam them. Whole cooking keeps water from leaching pigment through cut surfaces.

  2. Cook to just tender, a paring knife should slide in with slight resistance. Overcooking is the main cause of crumbly salad.

  3. Drain and spread on a sheet pan to cool completely before cutting. Warm potatoes absorb dressing but also shed starch and fall apart.

  4. Add acid (vinegar or lemon juice) to the dressing.

  5. Fold, do not stir. Use a rubber spatula and add dressing in stages.

Substitutions and sourcing: if you cannot find a named colored variety, a waxy red or yellow fingerling from a farmers market will behave similarly in texture, though you lose the color contrast. Rare fingerlings are seldom stocked in ordinary grocery stores; where to find rare fingerling potatoes covers the channels that do carry them, and a sample of Kerrs Pink lets you test the texture before buying a larger quantity.

Watch out: do not dress a colored potato salad hours ahead if appearance matters, acid helps, but prolonged contact with a watery dressing still dulls the surface color. Dress close to serving and keep the salad chilled.

Sourcing Seed Potatoes for Your Own Colored Varieties

Growing your own colored potatoes starts with clean seed stock. Early generation seed, such as FY1 and single-drop seed potatoes, is a common starting point for home growers. Our operation focuses on early generation and single-drop seed potatoes.

Pricing depends on variety, quantity, dates, and delivery, so check the Soda Springs Solar Gardens LLC website for current prices or a quote. If you are comparing sources, 9 places to buy small seed potatoes lists several options for buyers who want only a few pounds for a backyard plot.

Ask any seed seller about certification and testing before you buy, and keep records of what you plant where.

Growing and cooking rare colored potatoes is one of the most rewarding ways to expand your kitchen and garden. Soda Springs Solar Gardens LLC offers early generation, pathogen-free seed potatoes for home gardeners who want specialty varieties that garden centers rarely stock. Browse our selection and get started with the varieties that suit your plot.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the multicolored potatoes called?

Multicolored potatoes are usually sold under their variety names rather than a single category. Many have purple, red, or blue skin and flesh, and some heritage types show marbled or ringed interiors. Names vary by grower, so check the variety name on the seed tag or product listing before you plant or buy. Asking a seller for the flesh color, skin color, and intended use will help you match the variety to your cooking plans.

Do purple potatoes keep their color when cooked?

Color retention depends on the variety and the cooking method. Purple and blue flesh usually holds its color best when roasted or steamed, because it cooks in less water. Boiling can leach pigment into the water and fade the flesh. Cutting the potatoes into larger pieces and avoiding long soaking before cooking also helps keep the color vivid. Results vary, so test a small batch if color matters for a dish.

Which heirloom potatoes are best for roasting?

Waxy-to-medium heirloom varieties with firm flesh generally roast well because they hold their shape and crisp at the edges. Fingerling types roast quickly and evenly. Starchier heirloom varieties give fluffier interiors but can break apart if you stir them too often. For the best results, toss the potatoes in a little oil, spread them in a single layer, and roast at a high temperature until the edges are golden.

What are the best fingerling potatoes for salads?

Fingerling potatoes with waxy, moist flesh are the most reliable choice for potato salad because they keep their shape after boiling and cooling. Red and yellow fingerlings are common options and tend to hold their texture well in dressings. Let the potatoes cool slightly before dressing them so they absorb flavor without turning mushy. Cutting them in halves or rounds gives a clean, even look on the plate.

 
 
 

Comments


© 2018 by Soda Springs Solar Gardens LLC. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page